In a recent episode of the “Joe Rogan Experience” podcast, the enigmatic entrepreneur and tech mogul, Elon Musk, owner of Twitter (now known as X) and CEO of Tesla and SpaceX, raised questions about the nature of non-fungible tokens (NFTs). His critique inadvertently brought to light the potential of Bitcoin Ordinals, a unique aspect of the Bitcoin blockchain. In this article, we’ll explore Musk’s comments and the subsequent buzz surrounding Bitcoin NFTs.
Musk’s Take on NFTs
Elon Musk’s argument, delivered during the October 31 episode of the Joe Rogan podcast, was succinct: “The funny thing is the NFT is not even on the blockchain — it’s just a URL to the JPEG. If the company housing the image goes out of business, you don’t have the image anymore.” Musk’s remarks address a legitimate concern in the world of NFTs, where ownership can be precarious, relying heavily on the hosting company’s existence.
The Bitcoin Ordinals Solution
In the aftermath of Musk’s podcast appearance, a surge of interest in Bitcoin Ordinals emerged within the crypto community. Bitcoin Ordinals are a form of NFTs on the Bitcoin blockchain that came into existence following the Taproot soft fork in November 2021, introduced by developer Casey Rodarmor in January.
One of the core advantages of Bitcoin Ordinals is that they inscribe data directly onto the Bitcoin blockchain, providing a solution to the very issue Musk highlighted regarding the permanence of digital assets.
The Birth of Bitcoin NFTs
Developer Casey Rodarmor introduced Bitcoin NFTs on January 21, 2023, empowering users to securely attach various data, including images and videos, to the Bitcoin blockchain. Musk’s suggestion was simple but profound: “You should at least encode the JPEG in the blockchain. If the company housing the image goes out of business, you don’t have the image anymore.”
The Crypto Community’s Response
One passionate Bitcoin enthusiast, known as Leonidas, a staunch supporter of Ordinals, took it upon himself to inscribe the Musk podcast episode video clip into the Bitcoin blockchain. His message was clear: Bitcoin NFTs (Ordinals) are stored fully on-chain forever.
I just inscribed the video of @elonmusk saying that NFTs are "not even on the blockchain" into the Bitcoin blockchain!
Engage so that this shows up in Elon's timeline and he learns about how Bitcoin NFTs (Ordinals) are stored fully on-chain forever.
— Leonidas (@LeonidasNFT) November 1, 2023
Rohun “Frank” Vora, notable for creating NFT projects DeGods and y00ts, lauded Bitcoin Ordinals for offering a sophisticated solution to a widespread critique of NFTs. Even Billy Markus, the co-creator of Dogecoin and a supporter of Musk’s views, acknowledged the advantages of Ordinals over traditional NFTs.
This is why Ordinals will continue to grow.
It's the most elegant solution to one of the most universal criticisms of NFTs. https://t.co/feVYFbv7eL
— DeGod #2505 (@frankdegods) November 1, 2023
The Growing Popularity of Bitcoin NFTs
The number of Ordinal inscriptions on Bitcoin has already surpassed 36 million, according to Dune analytics. Since their inception, Bitcoin NFTs have gained traction within the NFT community and have been adopted by many companies.
However, it’s important to note that Musk’s comments may not be universally applicable. Some projects on Ethereum, the leading blockchain for NFTs, have their artwork stored on-chain, ensuring their immutability and resistance to censorship.
The NFT Misconception
The discussion also highlights a common misunderstanding about NFTs. An NFT represents ownership of a digital or physical asset, but it’s not the asset itself. Depending on the project, the associated asset may be stored on a decentralized blockchain, making it immutable and resistant to censorship, or it may be off-chain.
The Rise of Bitcoin NFT Marketplaces
In recent months, several developments in the Bitcoin NFT space have further bolstered its appeal. Magic Eden introduced a Bitcoin NFT marketplace for digital artifacts in March, being the first fully audited platform in the Bitcoin Ordinals ecosystem. Binance also added Bitcoin NFTs to its NFT Marketplace in May.
Furthermore, Metagood, the creators of OnChainMonkeys, disclosed plans to transition their NFT collection from the Ethereum blockchain to Bitcoin. The move signifies a shift towards the superior security infrastructure of the Bitcoin Ordinal protocol.
Ethereum’s Continued Dominance
Despite the potential of Bitcoin Ordinals and the arguments for on-chain storage, Ethereum continues to dominate the NFT market. As of June, data from CoinGecko indicates that Ethereum (ETH) accounts for 84% of all NFT trading volumes, with Bitcoin and ImmutableX holding 11% and 2.5% market shares, respectively.
Elon Musk’s candid remarks on NFTs inadvertently shone a spotlight on Bitcoin Ordinals, highlighting their ability to securely store data on the blockchain. While Bitcoin NFTs offer a promising solution, the NFT landscape remains diverse, with Ethereum leading the way.
1. What are Bitcoin Ordinals, and how do they differ from traditional NFTs?
Bitcoin Ordinals are a unique form of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) that are created on the Bitcoin blockchain. They differ from traditional NFTs in their method of data storage. While traditional NFTs often rely on external hosting of digital assets, which can be vulnerable if the hosting company goes out of business, Bitcoin Ordinals encode data directly onto the Bitcoin blockchain. This means that the data associated with a Bitcoin Ordinal is stored on-chain, providing a higher level of permanence and security compared to traditional NFTs.
2. Why did Elon Musk’s comments on NFTs create such a buzz in the crypto community?
Elon Musk’s comments on NFTs generated significant attention within the crypto community because of his influential status and the inherent validity of his critique. Musk’s observation that many NFTs are merely links to external content and not actually stored on the blockchain highlighted a genuine concern within the NFT space. This critique inadvertently brought to light the potential of Bitcoin Ordinals, which address the very issue Musk raised by securely storing data on the Bitcoin blockchain. Musk’s endorsement, even if unintended, carried weight and sparked a broader discussion on the future of NFTs.
3. Are Bitcoin NFTs the future of digital asset ownership?
While Bitcoin NFTs, or Ordinals, offer a promising solution for securely storing digital assets on the blockchain, it’s essential to recognize that the NFT landscape is diverse. Ethereum has been the dominant blockchain for NFTs, and it continues to hold a significant market share. Whether Bitcoin NFTs become the future of digital asset ownership depends on various factors, including user adoption, developer support, and the evolution of the technology. The future might involve a combination of different blockchain solutions for various use cases.
4. How does the NFT misconception affect the industry?
The NFT misconception, where people sometimes confuse the NFT itself with the underlying digital or physical asset, can lead to misunderstandings and misinterpretations. It’s crucial to understand that an NFT represents ownership or provenance of an asset, but it doesn’t necessarily store the asset itself. This misconception can impact how NFTs are perceived and valued. It’s essential for the industry to educate users and collectors about the true nature of NFTs to ensure transparency and informed participation.
5. Which blockchain currently dominates the NFT market, and why?
As of the available data, Ethereum (ETH) continues to be the dominant blockchain in the NFT market, accounting for a substantial portion of all NFT trading volumes. Ethereum’s dominance is attributed to its early adoption of NFT technology, a well-established ecosystem, and broad support from artists, creators, and developers. It has become the go-to platform for minting, buying, and selling NFTs. However, other blockchains, including Bitcoin, are increasingly making strides in the NFT space, offering unique features and solutions that might impact the landscape in the future.
Follow us on our social networks and keep up to date with everything that happens in the Metaverse!